A lot of care is taken when selecting our judging panel. We work hard to ensure the judging of the Construction Marketing Awards remains impartial. We take care when allocating judging responsibilities for award categories, ensuring there is no conflict of interest with the judges for those entries.
Judging is a two-step process. With Judges reviewing entries online, and assessing against a set criteria. The next step is a formal judging meeting where this assessment is reviewed for fairness. This meeting is overseen by the Chair of Judges to ensure impartiality. During all stages judges are only able to view entries for their allocated category. At no point are they able to view entries from other categories. This ensures judging remains impartial.
On some categories there is a formal face-to-face judging interview in addition to the online review and judges meeting. If a category is subject to this process it will be clearly indicated.
In addition to the judging panel, the Construction Marketing Awards also utilises an Advisory Board. The CMA Advisory Board comprises of a group of volunteers, chosen from client organisations, who advise irregularly, providing guidance on particular questions relating to the Awards as and when they arise. For example the questions could relate to category development, or oversight of claims made on the basis of performance for award entries.
Graham Anderson
Director, Anderson Business Media Limited
Andy Cassie
Retired communications consultant
Mike Conway
Director, Camargue
Ian Exall (Chair of Judges)
Business Development Manager, Ravatherm
John Dickinson-Lilley
Head of Communications & Marketing, CITB
Jim Harris
Harris Associates
Anna Hern
Director, Ridgemount PR
David Hopkins
Managing Director, Timber Trade Federation
David Ing
Managing Director, Fabrick (formerly CFA)
James Lee
Head of Group Marketing and Communications, Glass and Glazing Federation
Mike Leonard
Chief Executive, Building Alliance
Rick Osman
CEO, Highwire Design; CIMCIG committee
Steven Plimmer
Group Product Manager – RIBA
Justin Ratcliffe
Chief Executive, Council for Aluminium in Building
Mike Rigby
CEO, MRA Marketing
Deborah Rowe
Consultant, Sheba Marketing; CIMCIG committee
Joanne Stark
Marketing Director, Carpet & Flooring, SIG plc
Jonathan Stock
Publishing Director, Architecture Today
Ross Sturley
Principal, Chart Lane; CIMCIG committee
Richard Watkins
Director, The Business Alchemists
Chris Witte
Group Marketing Director, BMI Group
Kevin Williams
Sales Director Pitched Roofing UK, Monier Redland
Mike Lomax
Marketing Communications Manager, Tarmac Cement
If you are concerned about your entry being seen by one or more of the judges, just contact us and we will make sure that your confidential information is only seen by judges for whom there is no conflict.
